When OCD Doesn’t Look Like OCD: The Complex World of Mental Compulsions

Say you’re driving home, and you go over a bump. For a second, you wonder if it was a person. You know it was a pothole, but you go over it anyway. You picture the road, replay the sound, and think about turning around to check. By the time you get home, you’ve spent twenty minutes on it, and the doubt still hasn’t fully gone away.

That’s a mental compulsion. Most people picture OCD as hand washing or flipping light switches, so they never connect it to what’s happening in their own head. I see a lot of clients who lived with this for years and first came in for “anxiety” or “overthinking.”

What a Mental Compulsion Actually Is

OCD runs on two things. Obsessions are the unwanted thoughts or images that show up and cause a spike of anxiety. Compulsions are whatever you do to bring that anxiety down. The International OCD Foundation describes compulsions as an attempt to escape or reduce the anxiety an obsession brings. Washing and checking count. So do replaying, counting, praying, and arguing with yourself in your head.

Doing the compulsion usually brings some relief, but it doesn’t last long. And every time you do it, your brain gets the message that the thought was a real threat. So the next time the thought comes up, the anxiety is stronger, and so is the urge to do the compulsion.

Part of why mental compulsions go unnoticed is that they look like regular thinking. Everyone replays an awkward conversation sometimes. With OCD, the difference is how much time you spend and how stuck you get. People with OCD can lose an hour or more a day to it, and trying to stop feels close to impossible.

The thoughts themselves also keep people quiet. Intrusive thoughts go after what you care about most, so a new mom gets thoughts about hurting her baby and someone in a happy relationship gets thoughts that they don’t really love their partner. Those are hard things to say out loud, even in a therapy room. In my experience, the people most upset by these thoughts are the people least likely to act on them.

What It Can Look Like

Mental compulsions vary from person to person, but a few come up repeatedly in my work.

Reviewing is one of the most common. You go back through a conversation from last night or something you did in college and search for evidence that you did nothing wrong. You rarely find a clear answer, so you start again.

Checking your feelings is another. Someone with relationship-focused OCD might look at their partner across the dinner table and ask themselves whether they feel enough. If the answer isn’t a clear yes, the panic starts.

Then there’s reassurance, which I think is the hardest one to give up. It can sound like asking your partner, “Are you sure you’re not mad at me?” for the fourth time that day, or telling yourself, “I would never do that,” until the fear eases up. Most people don’t experience reassurance as a compulsion. It feels like being careful, or like being a good partner.

Some people count or say a prayer a certain number of times. Some try to cancel out a bad thought with a good one. For example, if you picture your sister in a car accident, you might picture her safe at home to make up for it. A lot of people also try to argue the thought away and prove to themselves it isn’t true, but there’s always another doubt to answer.

Avoidance usually travels with all of this. You stop using the big kitchen knife, or you make excuses not to babysit, so the thought has less chance to show up.

Getting Out of Your Head

The treatment with the most research behind it is exposure and response prevention, or ERP. You face the thoughts and situations that trigger the obsession in small steps, and you practice not doing the compulsion. We’ve written more about how exposure works. With mental compulsions, response prevention means catching yourself mid-review and leaving the thought where it is, unsolved.

Catching it takes practice. Most of my clients are surprised once they notice how much of their day goes to checking and reviewing. Some keep a tally on their phone for a week to see the number.

Once you notice the compulsion, you can answer the thought differently. “Maybe, maybe not” is a phrase I use a lot with clients. It sounds too simple, and it’s uncomfortable at first because it leaves the question open. Your brain has to learn that it can get through not knowing, and it only learns by sitting in that discomfort.

Cutting back on reassurance is harder, partly because other people are involved. It helps to tell your partner or family what you’re working on. Then, when you ask the same question again, they can say something like, “That sounds like the OCD,” and leave it there.

Underneath most of this is a need for control and a level of certainty that nobody actually has. Acceptance and commitment therapy can also help here, since its goal is to let uncomfortable thoughts be there without fighting them.

If This Sounds Like You

If you’ve been stuck in your head for a long time, see a therapist who treats OCD specifically. Many people are told they overthink, and general talk therapy can become another place to get reassurance without anyone noticing. NAMI has a good overview of OCD and its treatment. At Gateway to Solutions, we work with OCD every day, including the kind nobody else can see.

Leave a Comment